Tag: Monitoring Analytics

  • Data Centers and Your Electric Bill: A Virginia Server Farm Can Raise a Jersey Shore Rate

    Data Centers and Your Electric Bill: A Virginia Server Farm Can Raise a Jersey Shore Rate

    Demand Case

    The searched question is: “Why did my New Jersey electric bill go up, and are data centers the reason?” I looked for a clean, sourced search volume for that question and did not find a number I could publish without inventing it. Plainly: no clean volume exists in the sources I could verify for this piece. The verified demand is in the bills and in Trenton’s response. The Board of Public Utilities certified increases of 17.23 to 20.20 percent taking effect June 1, 2025, the Governor signed a data center rate law on July 7, 2026, and the BPU is still taking comment on implementing it in November 2026. Legislatures do not write new rate classes for a question nobody is asking.

    Three Different Fights, and This One Is Money

    I have covered data centers three ways on Exit Desk already. One fight is water. One is whether your town can say no. This one is money, through a regional market most people never heard of until it showed up on their bill.

    New Jersey sits inside PJM Interconnection, the wholesale grid covering 13 states and the District of Columbia. A data center does not have to be in your town, or even in this state, to affect what you pay here.

    Rutgers researchers made that point on October 29, 2026. A minimal amount of the new demand driving the regional price is physically in New Jersey, they wrote. A massive data center in Virginia can raise bills here. In their 24 state study, New Jersey has 50 operational facilities and about seven million square feet of data center space, much of it older finance and telecom space. Virginia has 552 facilities. Texas has 651.

    The Auction That Hit Your June 2025 Bill

    PJM pays power plants to be available at peak times through its Base Residual Auction. Think of it as paying for a promise. The plant gets paid to be ready, whether or not it runs on the hottest day. Capacity is one part of your bill, alongside energy, transmission, and delivery. It is not the whole bill.

    PJM’s own numbers: for 2024/2025, the auction cleared at $28.92 per megawatt-day, about $2.2 billion total. For 2025/2026, announced July 30, 2024, it cleared at $269.92 per megawatt-day for much of PJM. PJM procured 135,684 megawatts for June 1, 2025 through May 31, 2026, and total cost rose to $14.7 billion. Roughly nine times the unit price in one step.

    The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities connected that auction to your mailbox. On February 12, 2025, the Board certified the Basic Generation Service results for PSE&G, Atlantic City Electric, Jersey Central Power and Light, and Rockland Electric. It projected average monthly increases beginning June 1, 2025 ranging from 17.23 percent to 20.20 percent, depending on territory. In its June and August 2025 orders, the Board said those increases largely stem from the July 2024 PJM auction. You did not use 20 percent more electricity that June. The promise got more expensive.

    It did not snap back. PJM’s summary shows $329.17 for 2026/2027 and $333.44 for 2027/2028, with a later auction at $325. The BPU’s June 30, 2026 order says the June 1, 2026 state changes were much smaller, from a 1.8 percent decrease to a 1.6 percent increase. The second June did not repeat the first June’s shock.

    What the Market Monitor Actually Said

    PJM has an Independent Market Monitor, Monitoring Analytics. It is the watchdog inside the market, not an advocacy group and not PJM’s press office. Rutgers, summarizing the monitor’s work, put it this way: the monitor estimated data center electricity demand drove 63 percent of that 2025/2026 capacity price increase. That translates to about $9.3 billion spread across the region.

    Hold that number correctly. It is a modeled estimate. The monitor reran the auction math with and without data center load, existing and forecast, and measured the gap. The detailed figure reported from its analysis is $9,332,103,858 in added 2025/2026 revenues attributable to data center load by itself. It is not a meter reading, and it will never appear as a line item on your bill. It is the strongest sourced attribution we have, and it is still a counterfactual.

    PJM’s forecast explains why forecast load matters. In an August 8, 2025 letter, the PJM Board wrote that its 2025 forecast shows peak growth of 32 gigawatts from 2024 to 2030, approximately 30 gigawatts of it from data centers. The auction prices expected demand before all of it is built. You pay today for a shortage the forecast expects tomorrow.

    The Honest Counterpoint, From Rutgers

    If I only gave you the $9.3 billion, I would be doing what I complain about. The same Rutgers team tested whether living near a data center raised local bills through 2024. Their answer was, in their words, “mostly not yet.” Across 22,834 ZIP codes in 24 states from 2014 to 2024, linked to 2,277 data centers, a nearby data center raised a typical bill by about $2.09 a month in their raw model, and that effect disappeared at the utility territory level. They also found a 4 to 5 year lag before a new data center affects local bills.

    That does not contradict the auction story. It locates it. The regional capacity effect that landed in June 2025 hits everyone on PJM whether a server farm is down their road or three states away. And the forward risk is real: PJM expects 70 gigawatts of new large load by 2038, while 15 gigawatts of older plants have retired since 2022.

    What Trenton Did, and What It Has Not Done Yet

    On July 7, 2026, Governor Mikie Sherrill signed the Data Center Fair Share Act, P.L. 2026, c.32, bills S731 and A796. The Governor’s office says it creates a new ratepayer class for large data centers, ensuring they pay for their own energy use and grid infrastructure. It incentivizes them to bring in cheap, clean power, requires them to cut back when the grid is strained before residential ratepayers are impacted, and creates a retail program outside PJM where a new large load can offset its capacity obligation by paying to reduce demand elsewhere.

    The same package announced a $25 bill credit for all 3.6 million New Jersey ratepayers, plus $150 for lower to moderate income families. The administration cited a Synapse Energy Economics estimate of more than $1 billion in annual savings. I am reporting that $1 billion as the administration’s cited estimate, not as money I verified on anyone’s bill.

    Here is what decides whether the law helps you. It is not in effect as a tariff yet. The Act requires the BPU to establish standards within 12 months. BPU staff opened Docket No. EO26080463 on October 19, 2026, and extended the comment deadline from November 13 to 5 p.m. on December 14, 2026. As of today, November 16, Trenton is still asking what “large” should mean. The rate class exists in statute. The tariff that would move dollars does not, and the BPU has until July 2027.

    A second law signed August 27, 2026, S3379 and A4096, requires semiannual energy and water reports to the BPU. You cannot argue fairly about who pays until you can see who uses what. A start, not a discount.

    My Bottom Line

    Your June 2025 increase was real, it was mostly a capacity story, and the market’s own monitor ties most of that spike to data center load, much of it forecast and much of it outside New Jersey. Your town fight over a server warehouse is a land and water fight. Your bill is a regional auction fight, won or lost at the BPU, at PJM, and at FERC, not at a planning board.

    Watch two dates. December 14, 2026 is when BPU comments on the Fair Share rules close. July 2027 is the deadline for the standards. If those rules land weak, the law is a press release. If they land with real cost allocation and real curtailment, the biggest new load on the grid finally pays like it.

    For the other sides of this boom, see How much water does a data center use? and Can your town ban a data center in New Jersey?

    Sources